SSU · measured by top3 champion share

Strength Survives Upsets

Context

Any single game is a coin with a bias. The best team in the league loses one in four to a good team on a given Saturday, and more than that on the road in the rain. A format is credible when, over many seasons, the champion is usually one of the strongest, and when an upset changes the story without making a nonsense of it.

Problem

A pure knockout has the best team playing for fifth after one bad Saturday; a pure standings race surprises nobody. Where the dial sits is a design choice, and it should be measured. And it should be measured under more than one kind of league, because a format that looks fine with one juggernaut can look foolish with eight even teams.

Forces

  • Variance pulls against drama. The upset is the sport's best product, but too much of it and the title is noise.
  • Variance pulls against second chances. Two cups lower the variance by giving the strong team another path, and they also give a hot team a second lottery ticket.
  • Variance pulls against parity. The same format behaves differently when strengths are spread than when they are bunched. The share of seasons with multiple cup champions can swing wildly on the spread alone.
  • Variance pulls against rivalry openers. A knockout opener against a rival is a coin flip with history on it, and the strongest team can lose it.

Solution

Simulate every format under the same strength draws at several settings of parity, and report how often a top-three team wins. Prefer formats whose credibility holds up across the settings. Show the slider on the site so nobody has to take our word for which world we assumed.

Therefore

Measure champion credibility explicitly, under more than one world, and show the slider.

Measure

The share of seasons in which the conference champion is among the three strongest teams by latent strength, at each parity setting.

Lore

The 2007 season had Appalachian State at the Big House in September and two-loss LSU holding the trophy in January, and the sport loved every minute of it until it had to explain the trophy. Upsets are the point of the sport, but a champion nobody believes in is where the fun stops.

Supported by

Pulls against EGC Every Game CountsDEF Decisive FinalRIO Rivalry in the Opener

Seen in

scenariolanguagesimulatedvalue
status-quo+ honors+ honors0.855
pool-play~ strains~ strains0.832
two-cups+ honors+ honors0.867
two-cups-b~ strains~ strains0.812
four-cups+ honors+ honors0.855
pools-playoff~ strains~ strains0.847
mini-playoff~ strains~ strains0.831
chase+ honors+ honors0.857
seven-settle+ honors+ honors0.860
seven-final~ strains~ strains0.834
seven-semis+ honors+ honors0.858
eight-final~ strains~ strains0.849
  • status-quo: honors. Nine-game standings; a top-three team wins about five seasons in six (0.85), right on the bar once seasons of every parity are counted.
  • pool-play: strains. Two round robins, but the title is three games in the top pool; a top-three team wins about four seasons in five.
  • two-cups: honors. Two full championships give the strong two roads; a top-three team wins nearly nine seasons in ten.
  • two-cups-b: strains. When the champions already met, the earlier result stands, so an upset in a cup can be the title (0.80).
  • four-cups: honors. The second stage protects credibility; a top-three team wins about six seasons in seven.
  • pools-playoff: strains. Win your pools and then a bracket; a top-three team wins about five seasons in six.
  • mini-playoff: strains. Knockout pods and then a knockout bracket leave the strongest team exposed.
  • chase: honors. Nine in the standings, with the hard ones last.
  • eight-final: strains. Eight games sort the table before one final, which the strongest can lose; a top-three team wins about five seasons in six (0.85), right on the line, and the sample has put it on either side of it.
  • seven-settle: honors. Seven games and then two title weekends among the top of the table; a top-three team wins about six seasons in seven (0.86).

See it: status-quopool-playtwo-cupstwo-cups-bfour-cupspools-playoffmini-playoffchaseseven-settleseven-finalseven-semiseight-final