EGC · measured by consequence share

Every Game Counts

Context

Ask anybody who has sat in a stadium in October with their team undefeated what the game felt like, and they'll tell you it felt like a playoff game, because it was one: lose, and the season changes shape. That feeling is what a format should produce, and the rest of the structure is there to produce it.

Problem

In a fixed nine-game schedule, most of that feeling drains out by November. A 7-0 team has clinched, a 2-5 team is playing out the string, and two 4-3 teams meeting on the third Saturday of November get nothing from the result but the win. The game is still football, but it isn't a playoff game anymore, and the people in the stands know it.

Forces

  • Consequence pulls against sample. The more one Saturday decides, the fewer Saturdays the title rests on.
  • Consequence pulls against mercy. If every game is life or death, the eliminated have nothing to play for by midseason.
  • Consequence pulls against foresight. A game can only carry weight if something downstream depends on it, which usually means an opponent or a round that is not yet fixed.
  • Early pulls against late. A fixed schedule concentrates meaning wherever the contenders happen to land, and a format should spread it across the calendar on purpose.

Solution

Build the season so that each result changes the school's path. Knockout rounds do this by definition, rank bands and Swiss pairing do it by letting the standings choose the next opponent, and Gumbo structures do it for the schools out of the race. Look for any stretch where a school's remaining opponents and its possible outcomes are both already settled, and design it out.

Therefore

Prefer formats where a school's next opponent, next round, or final place depends on this Saturday's result, for every school, in every week.

Measure

The share of conference games whose result changes something: a participant's chance of winning the conference by more than a threshold, or who a participant plays next, or where. We estimate it by conditional replay, playing the game both ways with everything before it held and the same luck after it in both branches, so the difference between the branches is the game. Beside it we report the title part alone and the path part alone, so hope is visible separately from the title.

Lore

Ohio State played Michigan in 2006 as first against second on the last Saturday, with the winner going to the national title game, a day after Bo Schembechler died. The Big Ten's structure had no part in making that game; the calendar got lucky, and this pattern is about building a season that doesn't need the luck.

Supported by

Pulls against SMP Sufficient SampleSCH Second ChanceBID Protect the Bids

Seen in

scenariolanguagesimulatedvalue
status-quo~ strains~ strains0.404
pool-play× breaks× breaks0.393
two-cups+ honors+ honors0.805
two-cups-b+ honors+ honors0.789
four-cups+ honors+ honors0.729
pools-playoff+ honors+ honors0.771
mini-playoff+ honors+ honors0.727
chase+ honors+ honors0.784
seven-settle+ honors+ honors0.813
seven-final+ honors+ honors0.786
seven-semis+ honors+ honors0.813
eight-final+ honors+ honors0.745
  • status-quo: strains. By November most games decide nothing for either side; two in five move a title chance (0.40), right on the line between strains and breaks.
  • pool-play: breaks. Only the top rank pool's three games decide anything; the lower pools play for places, and a pool game moves a school's place less than half the time (0.40).
  • two-cups: honors. Every cup game is a knockout for the cup, and the second cup makes an early loss survivable without making it meaningless.
  • four-cups: honors. The same holds at eight-team scale.
  • pools-playoff: honors. Six games pick the eight, and the playoff games are knockouts.
  • mini-playoff: honors. Four pod knockouts and two rivalry games, then a knockout.
  • chase: honors. A standings race with record-based pairing keeps every result live.

See it: status-quopool-playtwo-cupstwo-cups-bfour-cupspools-playoffmini-playoffchaseseven-settleseven-finalseven-semiseight-final (the simulator replays every game both ways and fades the ones that changed nothing)