WPL · measured by same record share
Winners' Path, Losers' Path
Supports SORT Like Plays LikeCSF Super Final When EarnedEGC Every Game CountsLPL Like Plays LikeNPC No Poll, No Committee, No Coin FlipPHS A Gumbo Game Has StakesSCH Second ChanceTTE Title Event
Context
A classification tournament is a knockout where nobody goes home. Olympic team sports use it, and so does every youth soccer weekend in America. Winners play winners toward the trophy and losers play losers toward a place. After three rounds of eight, every one of the eight has a number next to its name and every one of them played every round.
Problem
An ordinary knockout sends half the field home each week, and in a conference nobody goes home; they just play games that do not count. A round robin keeps everybody playing but never separates the field. Neither gives every school a path with stakes in every round.
Forces
- Full participation pulls against drama. Everybody plays, but the losers' games have to be made to matter.
- Structure pulls against flexibility. A rigid bracket fixes venues at the cost of repeats with the other bracket, and a flexible consolation reduces repeats at the cost of structure.
- Scale. Sixteen needs four rounds and eight needs three; two eights give two champions where one sixteen gives one.
- The winners' path pulls against the league's bids. Four straight games against unbeaten teams is a fine way to find a champion and a hard way to keep four teams looking like playoff teams.
Solution
Run the stage as a classification bracket. Round one is seeded and fixed. Each later round pairs schools with identical records in that stage, winners toward the final and losers toward Gumbo finals. Fix the home-and-away pattern of every bracket position before the season.
Therefore
Use a classification bracket for any knockout stage where every school must play every week.
Measure
The share of games in adaptive stages where both participants have identical win-loss records within that stage.
Lore
The NCAA basketball tournament played a third-place game until 1981. The World Cup still does. The teams playing in it would rather be somewhere else, and they play anyway, and some of those games have been better than the final. Nobody has to be told that fifth place is a real thing when there is a game for it.
Supported by
PSS Published SaturdaysHAB Home/Away Balance
Pulls against FOP Fresh Opponent PreferredBID Protect the Bids
Seen in
| scenario | language | simulated | value |
|---|---|---|---|
| status-quo | × breaks | · n/a | |
| pool-play | + honors | + honors | 0.630 |
| two-cups | + honors | + honors | 0.865 |
| two-cups-b | + honors | + honors | 0.863 |
| four-cups | + honors | + honors | 0.846 |
| pools-playoff | + honors | + honors | 0.717 |
| mini-playoff | + honors | + honors | 0.847 |
| chase | + honors | + honors | 0.461 |
| seven-settle | + honors | + honors | 0.973 |
| seven-final | + honors | + honors | 1 |
| seven-semis | + honors | + honors | 0.954 |
| eight-final | + honors | + honors | 1 |
- status-quo: breaks.
- pool-play: honors. Rank bands pair equals after the first stage.
- two-cups: honors. Four-round classification, every school every round.
- four-cups: honors. Three-round classification, twice.
- pools-playoff: honors. Inside the playoff and Gumbo stages, most games are between equal stage records.
- mini-playoff: honors. Pod second rounds are winner against winner and loser against loser.
- chase: honors. Swiss pairing is the continuous version.
See it: status-quopool-playtwo-cupstwo-cups-bfour-cupspools-playoffmini-playoffchaseseven-settleseven-finalseven-semiseight-final