HAB · measured by home balance
Home/Away Balance
Supports KNOW Fans Know Where and WhenCBC Cross-Bracket ConsolationFVA Fixed Venue, Adaptive OpponentNSC Neutral-Site ClassicPSS Published SaturdaysWPL Winners' Path, Losers' Path
Context
Nine conference games is an odd number, so every school gets four or five conference home games and the rotation alternates which. A home game is a seven-figure Saturday for the town, so the difference between four and five is seven figures, and a year with three is a letter from the athletic director.
Problem
Adaptive formats assign venues by bracket position, and a school's positions across two stages can stack to six home games or three. Inside a single classification bracket, exact balance is impossible for everybody: sixteen positions carry sixteen different four-game patterns, and only six of them are two home and two away.
Forces
- Balance within a stage pulls against balance across the season. No bracket can balance every school within one stage, but two brackets built as mirror images of each other can balance every school across the season.
- Balance pulls against the published rotation. Once the protected games are pinned to their published hosts, there is less room to flip everything else.
- Balance pulls against neutral ground. A neutral classic has to count as somebody's home slot for the arithmetic to work, and that school gets no gate from it.
Solution
Assign home and away to the fixed games so every school's early-stage homes balance; that assignment always exists when every school has an even number of fixed games. Give each school mirror-image bracket positions across the two stages, home in one where it was away in the other. Charge each neutral classic as a home slot to one school by the published rotation. Then check, with a flow model, that four or five home games is reachable for every school on every path through the season.
Therefore
Every school finishes with four or five designated conference home games, every year.
Measure
The share of schools finishing with four or five home-designated conference games, and the worst case observed.
Lore
Euler proved in 1736 that you can walk every bridge of Königsberg once and come home only if every landmass has an even number of bridges. The same idea says that if every school has an even number of fixed games, you can assign home and away to all of them so the homes balance. The oldest theorem in graph theory was about taking a walk, and it turns out to also be about where Vanderbilt plays in October.
Supported by
NSC Neutral-Site ClassicPSS Published Saturdays
Seen in
| scenario | language | simulated | value |
|---|---|---|---|
| status-quo | + honors | + honors | 1 |
| pool-play | + honors | + honors | 1 |
| two-cups | + honors | + honors | 0.960 |
| two-cups-b | + honors | + honors | 0.965 |
| four-cups | ~ strains | ~ strains | 0.890 |
| pools-playoff | ~ strains | ~ strains | 0.872 |
| mini-playoff | × breaks | × breaks | 0.698 |
| chase | + honors | + honors | 1 |
| seven-settle | + honors | + honors | 0.954 |
| seven-final | + honors | + honors | 0.988 |
| seven-semis | ~ strains | ~ strains | 0.946 |
| eight-final | + honors | + honors | 0.956 |
- status-quo: honors. The published rotation balances it.
- pool-play: honors. Home and away are set by pool position before the season.
- two-cups: honors. The two championships balance each other: a school home every round in one is away every round in the other, and all but two schools are home in exactly half their championship games. Those two even out with their ninth game, so everybody lands on four or five.
- two-cups-b: honors. The same positions as Two Cups, and with fewer finals there are fewer re-paired games to tip a school off four or five.
- four-cups: strains. The first six games can land anywhere from two home to four; the final rounds fix most of it.
- pools-playoff: strains. The early six can be three and three; the playoff decides the rest by rule.
- mini-playoff: breaks. Four fixed rounds pin enough hosts that a quarter of the league lands outside four or five under the first-draft orientation.
- chase: honors. Half the league is at four and half at five, fixed before the season.
- eight-final: honors. Four or five home games for nearly everyone; the final at the higher seed tips a school now and then.
- seven-semis: strains. Two weekends of semifinals and a final, each at the higher seed, tip a school off four or five a little more often than one final does (0.95, a hair under the bar).
See it: status-quopool-playtwo-cupstwo-cups-bfour-cupspools-playoffmini-playoffchaseseven-settleseven-finalseven-semiseight-final