FVA · measured by venue flips

Fixed Venue, Adaptive Opponent

Context

Chess avoids the venue problem because a board has no home, and Scotland's split admits every spring that some clubs will get an extra home game and some will lose one. Football can't avoid the problem, so the question is which of the two adapts, the venue or the opponent, and only one of them should.

Problem

If both venue and opponent depend on results, nobody can plan anything, and if both are fixed, nothing sorts. One of them has to be fixed, and it should be the venue, because the venue is what fans, police, and campuses plan around and the opponent is what they argue about.

Forces

  • Fixed venue pulls against pairing feasibility. With six home-designated and six away-designated schools on a Saturday, the solver must find a perfect matching across the two sets with no repeats and no reserved pairs. That is usually possible but not guaranteed, which is why the template is searched before the season.
  • Fixed venue pulls against venue sensitivity. Which schools host in which November weeks changes the repeat rate, and some templates never strand the solver while others strand it constantly.
  • Fixed venue pulls against the final. A title game between two schools with predetermined sites has a predetermined host, which may be wrong, which is why finals get their own rule.

Solution

Publish a venue template for every adaptive Saturday: which schools are home-designated, which away-designated, which bye. Each week, match home-designated against away-designated by minimum cost, with repeats and reserved rivals forbidden and record similarity rewarded. Search the template preseason, adversarially, for allocations that never strand the solver.

Therefore

Let the opponent change with the results, and never move the game.

Measure

Venue flips per season: games where a school plays at a site other than its published designation. Zero is achievable.

Supported by

Pulls against DEF Decisive FinalWPL Winners' Path, Losers' PathDFV Dynamic Field, Fair Venue

Seen in

scenariolanguagesimulatedvalue
status-quo· n/a· n/a0
pool-play+ honors+ honors0
two-cups~ strains~ strains2.020
two-cups-b~ strains~ strains1.800
four-cups× breaks× breaks4.410
pools-playoff× breaks× breaks5.151
mini-playoff× breaks× breaks5.640
chase+ honors+ honors0
seven-settle~ strains~ strains1.353
seven-final+ honors+ honors0.401
seven-semis~ strains~ strains1.495
eight-final+ honors+ honors0.252
  • pool-play: honors. Home and away are fixed by pool position before the pool is known.
  • two-cups: strains. Re-pairing by the rematch rule and in consolation moves a game or two a season off its designation.
  • four-cups: breaks. Three or so flips a season under the first-draft venue patterns, most of them where a repeat was the alternative; the template search is the fix.
  • pools-playoff: breaks. Several flips a season under the first-draft template, for the same reason.
  • mini-playoff: breaks. Under the first-draft November template, bracket and Gumbo games move off their designations several times a season. The fix is the template search rather than a change to the pattern.
  • chase: honors. No flips under the chosen template.
  • status-quo: not applicable; no opponent is chosen by results.
  • eight-final: honors. The final is at the higher seed and the displaced rivals play as the published home against the published away; a flip is rare.

See it: status-quopool-playtwo-cupstwo-cups-bfour-cupspools-playoffmini-playoffchaseseven-settleseven-finalseven-semiseight-final