KNOW

Fans Know Where and When

Context

A hundred thousand people come to a college town on a home Saturday, and the town gets ready months ahead: the hotels are booked in March, the police overtime is budgeted in the spring, and the student tickets go out in August. A family in Lubbock decides in June whether this is the year they drive to Baton Rouge. Every one of them needs the same thing, which Saturdays are home, which are away, and which are off. The opponent can wait.

Problem

Sorting means the opponent is not known until the results that pick it are in. If the venue moves with the opponent, nobody can plan anything, and a format that cannot say in August which Saturdays are home has failed the people who pay for it. The temptation is to promise everybody their stadium dates and then pick a playoff field by merit, and you cannot do both, as the Home/Away Pigeonhole pattern works out.

Forces

  • Knowing pulls against sorting. Every adaptive slot is a known opponent given up, and the format has to pick how many it gives up.
  • Known venue pulls against a chosen field. A knockout bracket has as many home-and-away patterns as it has positions, and a field picked by record will not usually bring one team for each of them.
  • Known venue pulls against the final. A final's site depends on who is in it. Either the site is neutral, or somebody's August promise is broken, or the rule for breaking it is published first.
  • Balance pulls against everything. Nine is an odd number, so every school wants four or five home games, and the template has to deliver that under every path.
  • Notice pulls against information. Pairing a week ahead gives the freshest matchup and the least time for anyone to plan.

Solution

Fix the venue and let the opponent come to you. Publish, before the season, a home, away, neutral, or bye label for every school on every Saturday. Use classification brackets, whose positions carry venue patterns, or a solved venue template over which adaptive opponents are matched. Where a knockout field must be chosen by merit, decide its venues by a rule published before the season, drawn by lot or chosen by placement, and never by whatever is convenient that week. Give as much notice of the opponent as the format allows.

Therefore

Promise the Saturdays in August and keep them in November, whatever the results.

Patterns

  • PSS, Published Saturdays. How many of the fourteen Saturdays are known preseason.
  • KOP, Known Opponents. How many of the nine opponents are known preseason.
  • HAB, Home/Away Balance. Whether every school lands on four or five homes.
  • FVA, Fixed Venue, Adaptive Opponent. How often a game moves from its published site.
  • HAP, Home/Away Pigeonhole. The limit that says why a chosen field cannot keep everybody's venues.
  • DFV, Dynamic Field, Fair Venue. When the field is chosen, whether the venue rule was written first.
  • NTC, Notice. How many days between knowing the opponent and kickoff.

Measure

Taken together: how many of a school's fourteen Saturdays are known in August, how many of its nine opponents, and how often a published venue is broken. A format honors this principle when the Saturdays are all known, the venues never move, and the opponents are known as far ahead as the sorting allows.

Lore

The Champions League rebuilt its group stage in 2024 into one big table where every club plays eight different opponents, four at home and four away, and the whole draw is made before a ball is kicked. They chose knowing over sorting, for the same reason we care about it: the people who travel. The Scottish split goes the other way and admits every spring that some clubs will get nineteen home games and others seventeen. Both leagues are open about the trade.

Supported by

Seen in

scenariolanguagesimulatedvalue
status-quo+ honors
pool-play+ honors
two-cups~ strains
two-cups-b~ strains
four-cups~ strains
pools-playoff~ strains
mini-playoff~ strains
chase+ honors
seven-settle+ honors
seven-final+ honors
seven-semis+ honors
eight-final+ honors
  • status-quo: honors. Everything is known years ahead.
  • pool-play: honors. Home and away are fixed by pool position before the pool is known.
  • two-cups: strains. The Saturdays are known, and most of the opponents are not.
  • four-cups: strains. The early Saturdays are known, and the final rounds depend on who gets there.
  • pools-playoff: strains. The playoff field is chosen by merit, so its venues need a rule.
  • mini-playoff: strains. The same holds.
  • chase: honors. All fourteen Saturdays are fixed, including the adaptive ones.