FOOT · the top of the language

Footballness

Context

College football is older than the forward pass, older than the radio that first carried it, and older than most of the stadiums it is played in. Rutgers and Princeton played the first game in 1869. Auburn and Alabama first met in 1893. Texas and Oklahoma have gone to the State Fair in Dallas since before the Second World War, and Florida and Georgia have met in Jacksonville about as long. Ole Miss and Mississippi State have played for a Golden Egg since 1927.

A school's football calendar runs a lot of family calendars too. There's the home opener, the road trip everybody saves for, rivalry week, and the Saturday after Thanksgiving when a whole state picks a side. Folks tailgate in the Grove under the same oaks their grandparents did.

We call all of that footballness: the rivalries, the stakes, the places, the dates, and the stories, built one Saturday at a time over a century and a half. Nobody designed it, and nobody could design it again from scratch.

Problem

The people who change a season are usually in a hurry, and footballness takes a long time to build. A format can look clean on a whiteboard and still cut a hundred-year rivalry, drain November of meaning, or crown a champion nobody believes in. The damage rarely shows in the first year, and it usually shows ten years on, when a game that used to stop a state has become one more game on a crowded Saturday.

Forces

  • The old pulls against the new. A rivalry that has lasted a hundred years has earned the benefit of the doubt, and a format drawn up last spring hasn't earned anything yet. The longer a tradition has lived, the longer it is likely to live, unless somebody breaks it.
  • The nation pulls against the conference. A bigger national playoff forgives a loss, and then two, so the conference has to give its own season back the stakes the national bracket takes away.
  • Money pulls against memory. Television wants a title game, and the fans want the Egg Bowl on its Saturday. Both are right, and a format has to answer to both.
  • Fairness pulls against tradition. A rivalry played every year is uneven by nature, because the same two schools meet whatever their records. A balanced schedule would rotate opponents, and a tradition keeps the same opponent on the same date.

Solution

Treat footballness as the whole and every other pattern as one of its parts.

  • Keep the rivalries where and when they have always been.
  • Make the season itself the playoff, so a Saturday in October still decides something.
  • Settle the title on the field, in games everybody saw.
  • Tell the fans where they'll be, early enough to plan the trip.
  • Fit it all inside the season the game already has, fourteen Saturdays and nine conference games.
  • Let it pay its way, because a format that cannot pay for itself won't last long enough to become a tradition.

Therefore

Change the season only in ways that keep what a century built, and judge every format by how much of it survives.

Measure

The Footballness score on the scorecard is the share of the patterns beneath this one that a format honors, with a strain counting half. It is the one number that tries to say everything at once, so we build it from all the other measures and from nothing else.

Lore

LSU beat Alabama 9–6 in overtime in November 2011. Two months later the two met again for the national championship, and Alabama won 21–0. The rematch was legal and the result was clean, and a lot of people still felt as if the first game had been taken back. That is the kind of loss this pattern is meant to notice, even when every rule was followed.

Supported by

How each format scores

scenarioFootballnesspatterns kept
Seven and a Final0.8822 honored, 7 strained, 0 broken
Championship Chase0.8623 honored, 4 strained, 2 broken
Seven and Settle0.8319 honored, 10 strained, 0 broken
Eight and a Final0.8120 honored, 7 strained, 2 broken
Seven and Semis0.7917 honored, 12 strained, 0 broken
Four Cups0.7820 honored, 7 strained, 3 broken
Pools and Playoff0.7818 honored, 11 strained, 1 broken
Pool Play0.7719 honored, 5 strained, 4 broken
Mini-Knockouts and Playoff0.7618 honored, 8 strained, 3 broken
Status Quo0.7516 honored, 4 strained, 4 broken
Two Cups0.7317 honored, 10 strained, 3 broken
Two Cups, no double jeopardy0.6815 honored, 11 strained, 4 broken

The full scorecard shows every pattern for every format.