FELD
Settled on the Field
Supports FOOT Footballness
Context
The whole moral claim of the sport is that the field decides. Auburn went undefeated in 2004 and was told by a formula that it could not play for the title. Oklahoma went to the 2008 Big 12 title game over a Texas team that had beaten it in Dallas, because a poll said so. In 1973 the Big Ten's athletic directors took a vote to decide who went to Pasadena. Every one of those left a mark, and every one of them was a case of somebody off the field deciding something the field could have decided.
Problem
Ties happen, and so do champions of parallel brackets, and two one-loss teams that never met. The moment the rules reach for a poll, a committee, a rating, a point total, or a coin, the title is being decided somewhere other than the field. A champion decided by arithmetic, with no game anybody knew was for the title, is legitimate and easy to forget.
Forces
- A final pulls against freshness. The two best teams have usually met already, so a real final is often a rematch.
- A final pulls against the calendar. The last Saturday belongs to the rivalries, so a final has to come earlier or be a rivalry game itself.
- A final pulls against knowing. A final's site depends on who is in it.
- Finality pulls against mercy. A two-team tie is settled fairly by the game they played. A three-team tie settled by anything other than the games they played, against each other and against the same opponents, is a guess dressed up as a rule.
- Results pull against the scoreboard. Breaking ties by points is tempting because points are always available, and it is also the fastest way to ruin the game being played.
Solution
Stage a real final on a known Saturday as the finalists' ninth game, re-pair whoever it leaves standing so nobody is abandoned, and let the scorecard carry the cost. There is never a tenth game. Settle a two-team tie by the game they played, and carry nothing else forward except what is needed to keep the next pairing fresh. Publish the whole tiebreak ladder before the season, results only, and let a three-way tie in a pool send nobody or everybody rather than reaching for a formula. Never let points scored or margin into the ladder.
Therefore
Decide the champion with games, under rules written before kickoff, and never with points, polls, or a coin.
Patterns
- DEF, Decisive Final. How often a game is played that everyone knows is for the title.
- CSF, Super Final When Earned. Whether two champions who have not met get to settle it.
- CFH, Only Head-to-Head Carries. Whether a two-team tie is settled by the game they played, and whether anything else leaks forward.
- NPC, No Poll, No Committee, No Coin Flip. How often the title is settled by results alone.
- WHM, Whom, Not How Much. Whether the ladder ever consults the scoreboard.
- STK, Something Stinks. The anti-pattern. It counts and shows the title-path games that replay a result the field already settled, a rematch a school has already won or a matchup across a gap of two wins in the standings.
Measure
Taken together: how often the title is decided by a game that was known to be for the title, and how often it is decided by results alone when it is not. A format honors this principle when there is nearly always a final, and the rest is settled by who beat whom.
Lore
Florida State went undefeated in 2023 and was left out by a committee that had watched its quarterback get hurt; Alabama got in by beating Georgia in Atlanta on the field. Both halves of that weekend belong to this principle: Alabama's half is what we want, and Florida State's half is what we are trying to make impossible.
Supported by
CRED The Champion Is CredibleDEF Decisive FinalCFH Only Head-to-Head CarriesNPC No Poll, No Committee, No Coin FlipCSF Super Final When EarnedWHM Whom, Not How MuchSTK Something Stinks
Seen in
| scenario | language | simulated | value |
|---|---|---|---|
| status-quo | ~ strains | ||
| pool-play | ~ strains | ||
| two-cups | + honors | ||
| two-cups-b | + honors | ||
| four-cups | + honors | ||
| pools-playoff | + honors | ||
| mini-playoff | + honors | ||
| chase | ~ strains | ||
| seven-settle | + honors | ||
| seven-final | + honors | ||
| seven-semis | + honors | ||
| eight-final | + honors |
- status-quo: strains. There is no title game, and the tiebreak ladder goes deep enough to reach the scoreboard.
- pool-play: strains. The title is settled by pool standings, where three-way ties happen.
- two-cups: honors. Knockout rounds, two cup finals, and a super final when the two cups have different champions.
- four-cups: honors. Cup finals and a final among the champions.
- pools-playoff: honors. There is always a final among the pool winners.
- mini-playoff: honors. The same holds.
- chase: strains. The champion comes from the standings, with no final.