CFH · measured by two way h2h share

Only Head-to-Head Carries

Context

When two schools finish a pool tied and they played each other, everybody in the building knows who should go through, and any rule that says otherwise will be booed. That is the one piece of a past result the sport agrees should reach forward, and almost nothing else should. A new stage is a new stage, and a team that lost in September shouldn't have to carry that loss into November.

Problem

A format that carries too much forward turns the season into one long standings table where early games outweigh late ones, while a format that carries nothing forward lets a tie between two schools who already settled it on the field be settled again by something other than the field.

Forces

  • Finality pulls against freshness. The game two schools played decides the tie between them, and it doesn't get to decide anything about a third school.
  • Memory pulls against the clean slate. Prior results are useful for one more thing, which is keeping the pairing fresh: a solver that remembers who played whom can steer the Gumbo games away from rematches.
  • Carry-forward pulls against the final. If an earlier result could decide the title, then the earlier game was a title game nobody knew about at kickoff, and that is the opposite of a decisive final.

Solution

Settle any two-team tie by the game those two played. Use earlier results in the pairing solver to steer placement and consolation games away from rematches whenever possible. Carry nothing else forward: no points, no records from another stage, and no prior meeting in place of a final.

Therefore

Let the game two schools played settle the tie between them, and carry nothing else forward except the memory of who has already met.

Measure

The share of two-team ties that are resolved by the head-to-head result, which should be all of them where the two have met, and beside it the share of Gumbo pairings steered away from a rematch by prior results.

Lore

Texas beat Oklahoma in Dallas in October 2008 and Oklahoma went to the Big 12 title game anyway, because the three-way tie reached a rung of the tiebreaker where a poll got a vote. The trouble came from reaching past the two-team case.

Supported by

Seen in

scenariolanguagesimulatedvalue
status-quo+ honors+ honors1
pool-play+ honors+ honors1
two-cups+ honors· n/a
two-cups-b+ honors· n/a
four-cups+ honors· n/a
pools-playoff+ honors+ honors1
mini-playoff+ honors· n/a
chase+ honors+ honors1
seven-settle+ honors+ honors1
seven-final+ honors+ honors1
seven-semis+ honors+ honors1
eight-final+ honors+ honors1
  • status-quo: honors. Standings tiebreaks begin with head-to-head.
  • pool-play: honors. Pool tiebreaks begin with head-to-head.
  • two-cups: honors. Nothing carries between cups in variant A, and the super final is played on the field. Variant B is the one place a prior meeting stands in for a final, by owner choice: a champion that already beat the other champion keeps its Thanksgiving game instead of playing a rematch, which is head-to-head doing exactly the job this pattern allows it.
  • four-cups: honors. The same as Two Cups.
  • pools-playoff: honors. Pool tiebreaks begin with head-to-head, and Gumbo pairing avoids rematches.
  • mini-playoff: honors. The same as Pools Playoff.
  • chase: honors. Standings tiebreaks begin with head-to-head.

See it: status-quopool-playtwo-cupstwo-cups-bfour-cupspools-playoffmini-playoffchaseseven-settleseven-finalseven-semiseight-final