NPC · measured by result only resolution share
No Poll, No Committee, No Coin Flip
Supports FELD Settled on the FieldCFH Only Head-to-Head CarriesWHM Whom, Not How Much
Context
Ties happen, and three schools at 2-1 in a four-team pool happen more often than you would think, as do two schools at 8-1 who never met. Every format needs a tiebreak, and the moment the tiebreak reaches for a rating, a committee, a point total, or a coin, the title has left the field and something else is deciding it.
Problem
Tiebreak ladders get long because somebody wanted every tie resolved, and a long ladder always ends somewhere ugly. A committee is a way of dressing up a coin flip, a rating is a committee you cannot argue with, and the coin at least tells you what it is.
Forces
- Result-only pulls against completeness. Head-to-head settles two teams. Three teams in a cycle cannot be settled by the games among them, and the games they each played against the same other schools are the only rungs below that which are still games; below those, every rung is a formula.
- Resolution pulls against the calendar. A play-in game costs a Saturday nobody has.
- Knockouts pull against round robins. Knockouts never tie, but round robins and standings do, and a knockout has to be seeded, which is a tiebreak in disguise.
- An unresolved tie pulls against a wrong one. Letting nobody advance from a three-way tie feels harsh, but letting the wrong team advance by formula feels worse and lasts longer.
Solution
Use structures that minimize ties: knockouts where possible, Swiss and rank-banded stages where not. Settle two-team ties by the game they played, and what that leaves by the games the tied schools played against the same opponents, highest-placed first. Below that, do not reach for a formula: either no team from the tie advances, or all of them do when the structure has room. Publish the whole ladder before the season, and report how often each rung is reached.
Therefore
Resolve the title with results alone in nearly every season, and make the remainder visible instead of hiding it in a formula.
Measure
The share of seasons in which the conference champion is determined by game results alone: record, head-to-head, and records against common opponents, without reaching a strength-of-schedule, scoring, or ratings rung.
Lore
In 1973 Ohio State and Michigan tied 10-10 and the Big Ten's athletic directors voted Ohio State into the Rose Bowl, six to four. Bo Schembechler never forgave them. In 2008 the Big 12 South ended in a three-way tie among Texas, Oklahoma, and Texas Tech, and a poll sent Oklahoma to the title game over a Texas team that had beaten it. If you win all your games nobody can touch you, and the ladder exists for everyone who did not.
Supported by
CFH Only Head-to-Head CarriesWPL Winners' Path, Losers' PathWHM Whom, Not How Much
Pulls against SMP Sufficient Sample
Seen in
| scenario | language | simulated | value |
|---|---|---|---|
| status-quo | ~ strains | ~ strains | 0.837 |
| pool-play | + honors | + honors | 0.908 |
| two-cups | + honors | + honors | 1 |
| two-cups-b | + honors | + honors | 1 |
| four-cups | + honors | + honors | 1 |
| pools-playoff | + honors | + honors | 1 |
| mini-playoff | + honors | + honors | 1 |
| chase | ~ strains | ~ strains | 0.896 |
| seven-settle | + honors | + honors | 1 |
| seven-final | + honors | + honors | 1 |
| seven-semis | + honors | + honors | 1 |
| eight-final | + honors | + honors | 1 |
- status-quo: strains. Nine-game standings tie often, and the published ladder runs deep.
- pool-play: honors. Four-team round robins produce three-way ties, and that is the format's biggest weakness, but the title itself is settled on results in nine seasons of ten (0.91), a hair over the bar.
- two-cups: honors. Knockouts settle the cups; only seeding into the super final needs a rule.
- four-cups: honors. Cup champions are decided by knockouts; the only draws are seeding draws, which are published rules.
- pools-playoff: honors. Pool winners by record and head-to-head; a pool with a three-way tie sends nobody; the title is settled on the field.
- mini-playoff: honors. Pod champions by knockout; a pod with no winner sends nobody by rule; the title is never settled by a draw.
- chase: strains. The ladder settles the standings title in nine seasons of ten (0.90 results-only), a hair under the bar once seasons of every parity are counted; what it leaves tied is co-champions, and that is rare.
See it: status-quopool-playtwo-cupstwo-cups-bfour-cupspools-playoffmini-playoffchaseseven-settleseven-finalseven-semiseight-final