The language

This is the list of what a good SEC season has to do, written as a set of connected ideas. At the top is Footballness, the whole thing. Under it are the big ideas, like keeping the rivalries and settling the title on the field, and under those the specific ones a format gets checked against. Each one says how we measure it. Start at the top and read down. Where this way of writing comes from.

FOOT · the top of the language

Footballness

Change the season only in ways that keep what a century built, and judge every format by how much of it survives.

In one breath

Footballness FOOT is what a century and a half of Saturdays has built, and a conference keeps it six ways.

Its Rivalries Are Kept RIVL: every Reserved Rivalry Pair RRP is named, the Thanksgiving Anchor TGA is held, there is a Rivalry in the Opener RIO wherever the draw allows, and each Neutral-Site Classic NSC stays on its date and its ground.

The Season Is the Playoff SEAS: Every Game Counts EGC because Early Results Shape Late Opponents ERL. That works when Like Plays Like SORT: the standings choose the opponent LPL along a Winners' Path, Losers' Path WPL, with a Fresh Opponent Preferred FOP, secured by Orthogonal Partitions ORP and Cross-Bracket Consolation CBC. And because most schools will not win it, there is Something to Play For HOPE: Placement Has Stakes PHS, every school gets a Second Chance SCH, and every stage ends with A Trophy to Lift TRO.

The title is Settled on the Field FELD: a Decisive Final DEF on a known Saturday, a Super Final When Earned CSF between two champions who have not met, Only Head-to-Head Carries CFH from one stage to the next, No Poll, No Committee, No Coin Flip NPC, and ties broken by Whom, Not How Much WHM; and when a title-path game replays a result the field already settled, Something Stinks STK, and we show it on the scorecard. Settled that way, The Champion Is Credible CRED, because Strength Survives Upsets SSU over a Sufficient Sample SMP.

Fans Know Where and When KNOW: Published Saturdays PSS, as many Known Opponents KOP as sorting allows, Home/Away Balance HAB, the rule of Fixed Venue, Adaptive Opponent FVA inside the Home/Away Pigeonhole HAP, a Dynamic Field, Fair Venue DFV by a rule written first, and as much Notice NTC as the sorting allows.

All of it Fits Inside the Season FITS: Nine and Done NIN, with a Bye Rhythm BYR a coach can live with.

And The Format Pays Its Way PAYS, with a real Title Event TTE that still Protects the Bids BID.

From the top down

RIVL Rivalries Are Kept supports Footballness

Name every rivalry's place in the season before the season starts, and keep it.

RRP · protected played

Reserved Rivalry Pair

Decide where each of the twenty-four is played before the season, as a fixed game or a reserved date, and let nothing override it but a final, which pays for the privilege here.

TGA · thanksgiving honored

Thanksgiving Anchor

Nothing adaptive happens on the last Saturday, except a final that happens to be a rivalry.

RIO · protected guaranteed

Rivalry in the Opener

Spend the fixed opening slots on rivalries, and let the knockout make the rivalry meaner.

NSC · neutral classics kept

Neutral-Site Classic

Keep the ground always and the date wherever the structure can bend; where it cannot, move the date and pay for it on this measure.

SEAS The Season Is the Playoff supports Footballness

Make every game count, by letting early results shape late opponents.

EGC · consequence share

Every Game Counts

Prefer formats where a school's next opponent, next round, or final place depends on this Saturday's result, for every school, in every week.

ERL · adaptive share

Early Results Shape Late Opponents

Make between a third and two thirds of the conference schedule adaptive, and never the rivalry games or the venues.

SORT Like Plays Like supports The Season Is the Playoff

Let standing choose the opponent, and build the stages so that standing rarely chooses the same opponent twice.

LPL · record gap late

Like Plays Like

Let standing choose the opponent in every adaptive slot, under a published rule.

WPL · same record share

Winners' Path, Losers' Path

Use a classification bracket for any knockout stage where every school must play every week.

FOP · repeat pairings

Fresh Opponent Preferred

Design so that seventy-two conference games are seventy-two different pairings, and measure how close each format gets.

CBC · consolation repeats

Cross-Bracket Consolation

Let losers cross brackets, and never let winners cross.

ORP · structural overlap

Orthogonal Partitions

Never let two schools share a group in both stages when the group size allows it.

HOPE Something to Play For supports The Season Is the Playoff

Make placement carry stakes, and give everyone a second chance, but never a third.

PHS · placement stakes share

A Gumbo Game Has Stakes

Make the structure for the eliminated as explicit as the structure for the contenders.

SCH · champion lost share

Second Chance

Give every school two structurally equal shots at the title, and never three.

TRO · trophies lifted

A Trophy to Lift

Every stage ends with something to lift.

FELD Settled on the Field supports Footballness

Decide the champion with games, under rules written before kickoff, and never with points, polls, or a coin.

DEF · decisive final share

Decisive Final

Stage a real final every year on a known date, or don't pretend to have one.

CFH · two way h2h share

Only Head-to-Head Carries

Let the game two schools played settle the tie between them, and carry nothing else forward except the memory of who has already met.

NPC · result only resolution share

No Poll, No Committee, No Coin Flip

Resolve the title with results alone in nearly every season, and make the remainder visible instead of hiding it in a formula.

CSF · super final share

Super Final When Earned

Play the super final as the ninth game, re-pair whoever it displaces so nobody sits out, let the scorecard carry the cost, and never play a tenth game.

WHM · scoreboard tiebreaks

Whom, Not How Much

Break ties by whom you beat, never by how much.

STK · title path smells

Something Stinks

Never ask the field a question it already answered.

CRED The Champion Is Credible supports Settled on the Field

Make most of a champion's games part of the case for the title, and check that the strong usually win it.

SSU · top3 champion share

Strength Survives Upsets

Measure champion credibility explicitly, under more than one world, and show the slider.

SMP · title sample games

Sufficient Sample

Make most of a champion's nine games part of the case for the title.

KNOW Fans Know Where and When supports Footballness

Promise the Saturdays in August and keep them in November, whatever the results.

PSS · saturdays known

Published Saturdays

Every school knows all fourteen of its Saturdays, every year, whatever the results.

KOP · opponents known

Known Opponents

Know at least the three protected opponents and the first stage before the season, and let results choose the rest.

HAB · home balance

Home/Away Balance

Every school finishes with four or five designated conference home games, every year.

FVA · venue flips

Fixed Venue, Adaptive Opponent

Let the opponent change with the results, and never move the game.

HAP · none

Home/Away Pigeonhole

Do not promise fixed venues and a merit-chosen knockout field at the same time. If you want the chosen field, publish how its venues will be decided before anybody is in it.

NTC · notice days

Notice

Maximize the days between an opponent's announcement and kickoff, and publish venues years ahead so notice is only ever about the opponent.

DFV · venue by rule share

Dynamic Field, Fair Venue

When the field is chosen by results, decide the venue by a rule written before the season, by lot or by placement, and never week by week.

FITS Fits Inside the Season supports Footballness

Play nine conference games in fourteen Saturdays, finish before December, and allow no exception you cannot name.

NIN · calendar fit

Nine and Done

A format that needs a result-dependent calendar fix it cannot name is not finished.

BYR · max streak

Bye Rhythm

Rule out long streaks in the template itself rather than fixing them after the fact.

PAYS The Format Pays Its Way supports Footballness

Produce title events you can sell in March, and do not send the league's best into December with losses the playoff committee will not forgive.

TTE · title events

Title Event

Put championship games on the calendar that a network can buy in March.

BID · league bids

Protect the Bids

Don't send the league's best teams into December with losses the playoff committee won't forgive, and say plainly how many bids a format costs.