TGA · measured by thanksgiving honored

Thanksgiving Anchor

Context

The Saturday after Thanksgiving is the last Saturday of the regular season and the one with the deepest roots. Five SEC pairs play it. Four SEC schools play ACC neighbors: Florida and Florida State, Georgia and Georgia Tech, Kentucky and Louisville, South Carolina and Clemson. Those four are contracts with another conference, and the SEC cannot move them alone. Everybody is home from school and full of dinner, and the game is on in every living room in the South.

Problem

Any structure that wants the last Saturday for a title round collides with nine rivalry games, four of which are not the SEC's to move. And there is a second worry: a Thanksgiving game played after the title was settled the week before has lost part of what made it matter.

That worry is misplaced. Those games happen every year with no bearing on the champion and they matter anyway; Auburn has ruined Alabama's November with nothing of its own to play for. The game holds without the title on it.

Forces

  • The anchor pulls against the final. A three-week playoff ending on the last Saturday is impossible for four schools and displaces five rivalries.
  • The anchor pulls against symmetry. The four ACC-rivalry schools need their ninth conference game earlier, so their November has a different shape from the other twelve.
  • The anchor pulls against the calendar. Fixing the last Saturday and the two October classics leaves eleven for everything else.
  • Double duty pulls the other way. When the two schools playing for the title are a Thanksgiving pair, the rivalry and the final are the same game, and that is the best Saturday the conference can have. The final moves to meet it.
  • The ACC games cannot do double duty. A Florida or Georgia final cannot slide to the last Saturday, so those four schools are a hard case, and we say so on the scorecard.

Solution

Treat the last Saturday as a fixed rivalry round. Finish every title structure a week earlier, with every school at eight games before the final so the final is the finalists' ninth. Give the four ACC-rivalry schools an earlier ninth conference game so they arrive at Thanksgiving with nine played. When the finalists are a Thanksgiving pair, slide the final to the last Saturday and play it as the rivalry, with the trophy on the line and the rivalry getting a bonus it did not ask for. When they are not, play the final here anyway if both their Thanksgiving opponents are being re-paired, and re-pair those two, rival with rival, or a rival into the ACC game the other finalist left, so nobody is abandoned; count every such game against the format here and in Reserved Rivalry Pair.

Therefore

Nothing adaptive happens on the last Saturday, except a final that happens to be a rivalry.

Measure

Of the nine Thanksgiving-weekend fixtures, five in-conference and four with the ACC, the number played as scheduled on the last Saturday, averaged across seasons; beside it the number re-paired because of a final, and the share of seasons in which a title game was played as a Thanksgiving rivalry.

Lore

Texas beat Texas A&M in College Station on the Saturday after Thanksgiving in 2024 and went to Atlanta because of it. The Kick Six in 2013 sent Auburn to the conference title game and Alabama home, on the last Saturday, with a hundred and nine yards of the best thing that ever happened on a football field. The last Saturday has never needed help mattering; it needs to be left alone.

Supported by

Pulls against DEF Decisive FinalCSF Super Final When EarnedTTE Title Event

Seen in

scenariolanguagesimulatedvalue
status-quo+ honors+ honors9
pool-play+ honors+ honors9
two-cups~ strains~ strains8.244
two-cups-b~ strains~ strains8.748
four-cups+ honors+ honors9
pools-playoff~ strains~ strains8.148
mini-playoff~ strains~ strains8.012
chase+ honors+ honors9
seven-settle~ strains~ strains8.175
seven-final+ honors+ honors9
seven-semis~ strains~ strains7.965
eight-final~ strains~ strains7.871
  • status-quo: honors.
  • pool-play: honors. The three fixed games include Thanksgiving.
  • two-cups: strains. Two championships fill eight games; the super final is the champions' ninth, and their Thanksgiving opponents are re-paired.
  • four-cups: honors. The final sits a week early and Thanksgiving is fixed.
  • pools-playoff: strains. Six fixed games and a three-round playoff; the final is the finalists' ninth, and their Thanksgiving opponents are re-paired.
  • mini-playoff: strains. The same shape, with the same re-pairing.
  • chase: honors. Three adaptive weeks end a week early.
  • eight-final: strains. The final is the finalists' ninth game, so it takes their Thanksgiving games most seasons, and the Saturday before it is the league's nonconference Saturday.

See it: status-quopool-playtwo-cupstwo-cups-bfour-cupspools-playoffmini-playoffchaseseven-settleseven-finalseven-semiseight-final