TTE · measured by title events

Title Event

Context

The SEC Championship Game sells out a neutral dome every December and gets a television window all to itself, and it has for thirty years. If that Saturday goes away, the conference needs something it can put in its place, something a network can buy in March and a fan can plan a weekend around. Four cup finals spread over two doubleheader Saturdays plus a final between the cup winners is more to sell than one game, as long as those finals mean something. A standings race with no final is less than one game, however good the race.

Problem

A format with no championship games on the calendar has nothing to sell against the old title game. A format whose championship games only happen some years can't be put in a contract, because a network won't pay for a game that might not be played.

Forces

  • Events pull against rivalries. Every championship game in November is competing with a rivalry game for the same Saturday and the same attention.
  • Events pull against fresh matchups. The most valuable final is the one between the two best teams, and the two best teams have usually already played each other.
  • Events pull against Gumbo games. The cup Gumbo finals are something to sell too, at a lower price, and nobody has worked out what that price is.

Solution

Count the championship games a format puts on the calendar every season: the cup finals, the semifinals, the final. Prefer the formats whose games fall on the same dates every year and whose teams are known a week ahead.

Therefore

Put championship games on the calendar that a network can buy in March.

Measure

We value a season's championship games against the old title game, which counts as one. The conference final is one, a semifinal is half, a quarterfinal a quarter. A sixteen-team cup's final is half, its semifinals a fifth each and its quarterfinals a tenth. An eight-team cup's final is about a third and its semifinals a tenth. A pod final is a tenth. A format that adds up to at least what the old game was worth gets a plus; half of that gets a tilde; less is an ×. We also report the plain count of games and how many of them were fresh matchups. The value model on the scenarios page puts dollars on the same games.

Lore

The ACC added a championship game in 2005, and the Big Ten and the Pac-12 added theirs in 2011, and every one of them did it for that one Saturday in December and the money that comes with it. A conference giving up that Saturday had better have something to show for it.

Supported by

Pulls against TGA Thanksgiving AnchorPHS A Gumbo Game Has Stakes

Seen in

scenariolanguagesimulatedvalue
status-quo× breaks× breaks0
pool-play× breaks× breaks0
two-cups+ honors+ honors3.259
two-cups-b+ honors+ honors2.824
four-cups+ honors+ honors3.836
pools-playoff+ honors+ honors2.432
mini-playoff+ honors+ honors3.378
chase× breaks× breaks0
seven-settle+ honors+ honors1.636
seven-final+ honors+ honors1
seven-semis+ honors+ honors1.744
eight-final+ honors+ honors1
  • status-quo: breaks. None.
  • pool-play: breaks. No final; the top pool's last round is the closest thing.
  • two-cups: honors. Two sixteen-team cup finals every year, their semifinals and quarterfinals, and a super final in most seasons: more than the old game, though no single game its equal.
  • four-cups: honors. Four cup finals and a bracket among champions ending in a final.
  • pools-playoff: honors. Quarterfinals, semifinals, final.
  • mini-playoff: honors. A final, semifinals and quarterfinals; the eight pod finals add little, since nobody buys a pod final at a championship's price.
  • chase: breaks. None.
  • seven-settle: honors. A final every year and semifinals in half of them.
  • seven-final: honors. One final, the old game's worth exactly.
  • eight-final: honors. The same final.
  • seven-semis: honors. Semifinals and a final every season, the old game and a half.

See it: status-quopool-playtwo-cupstwo-cups-bfour-cupspools-playoffmini-playoffchaseseven-settleseven-finalseven-semiseight-final