PHS · measured by placement stakes share
A Gumbo Game Has Stakes
Supports HOPE Something to Play ForEGC Every Game CountsTRO A Trophy to Lift
Context
Fifth place in a classification bracket is a real thing, because you played for it and beat somebody to get it, while fifth place in a standings table is a number somebody computed after the fact. The difference between those two is the difference between a November with something in it and a November without.
Problem
Formats that point all their structure at the title leave a dozen schools playing games with no defined objective. Bowl eligibility used to fill that hole and does not anymore; a committee's at-large line fills it for a few, and the rest get nothing.
Forces
- Stakes pull against simplicity. Sixteen named finishing positions mean something and are hard to sell. "Playing for seventh" needs a game attached to it or it is a punchline.
- Stakes pull against inventory. Gumbo games are television inventory only if the placements carry a consequence: bowl order, next year's seed, a tiebreak for the national bracket.
- Stakes pull against mercy. A winless team still needs a game it can win, and a place it can finish.
Solution
Give every school a defined finishing objective in every round: a cup Gumbo final, a pool rank, a standings tier. Attach a consequence to the finish. Call the Gumbo games what they are, in the schedule and on the broadcast.
Therefore
Make the structure for the eliminated as explicit as the structure for the contenders.
Measure
The share of conference games, in weeks after the first stage, in which both participants have a defined placement consequence riding on the result.
Lore
The old Southwest Conference used to say its champion got the Cotton Bowl and everybody else got what they got. The schools that got what they got stopped drawing. The beta pool in a rank-banded season carries the same weight as the second-class championship in the alpha pool, and that preserves the only argument that matters in this sport, which is that my team is better than yours.
Supported by
WPL Winners' Path, Losers' PathLPL Like Plays Like
Pulls against TTE Title Event
Seen in
| scenario | language | simulated | value |
|---|---|---|---|
| status-quo | ~ strains | ~ strains | 0.689 |
| pool-play | + honors | + honors | 0.841 |
| two-cups | + honors | + honors | 0.949 |
| two-cups-b | + honors | + honors | 0.946 |
| four-cups | + honors | + honors | 0.977 |
| pools-playoff | ~ strains | ~ strains | 0.768 |
| mini-playoff | + honors | + honors | 0.885 |
| chase | + honors | + honors | 0.882 |
| seven-settle | ~ strains | ~ strains | 0.594 |
| seven-final | ~ strains | ~ strains | 0.590 |
| seven-semis | ~ strains | ~ strains | 0.595 |
| eight-final | × breaks | × breaks | 0.436 |
- status-quo: strains. A standings position carries only indirect meaning.
- pool-play: honors. Every pool has a rank and every rank has a next pool.
- two-cups: honors. Classification settles all sixteen places in each cup.
- four-cups: honors. Each cup settles eight places.
- pools-playoff: strains. Gumbo games are played but not organized into finishing positions.
- mini-playoff: honors. Nearly nine late games in ten are a knockout, a Gumbo game, or a rivalry.
- chase: honors. The standings are the whole structure; every game moves a position.
- eight-final: breaks. The eighth game is a rotation game with nothing named at stake; only the final and the re-paired games are games for something.
See it: status-quopool-playtwo-cupstwo-cups-bfour-cupspools-playoffmini-playoffchaseseven-settleseven-finalseven-semiseight-final