TRO · measured by trophies lifted
A Trophy to Lift
Supports HOPE Something to Play For
Context
College football hands out hardware like no other sport: a golden egg, a golden boot, a ten-gallon hat in gold, a two-hundred-pound map of two states. The Jacobs Blocking Trophy has gone to the conference's best blocker since 1935, and the title game has named a most valuable player every year since Antonio Langham in 1992. A trophy is how a Saturday is remembered. It sits in a case in the football building, it is carried across the field, it is the thing a senior is photographed holding. A format with stages, cups and pools and finals, has places to put a trophy, while a standings table has one, handed over in December by a committee.
Problem
A stage that ends without a trophy is a stage nobody remembers winning. Cup A1 is a label on a bracket; the Thomas Cup is a thing a school wins and the next school takes away. Without a name and an object, a cup final is a game with bracket consequences, and a pool title is a line in a table. The format has done the work of making the stage and left the prize on the table.
Forces
- Trophies pull against freshness. Every stage with its own trophy is another stage, and more stages mean more rematches.
- Trophies pull against Thanksgiving. A final worth a trophy is a final worth a Saturday, and the Saturdays are spoken for.
- A trophy needs a game. A cup lifted after the final that decided it is a trophy, while a pool title read off a table on Sunday morning is a plaque, still worth having but worth less.
- A name has to be earned. A trophy named for a sponsor is a billboard, so the name should come from the conference's own history.
Solution
Give every stage a school can win a trophy with a name drawn from the conference's own history, and hand it over on the field after the game that decided it. Count a stage whose winner is read from a table as half a trophy, and a title decided by a final as a whole one. Prefer formats that produce three or more trophies a season, one of them the conference championship itself.
Therefore
Every stage ends with something to lift.
Measure
Trophies lifted per season: one for each stage decided by a game its winner won, a cup final, a pod final, the conference final; one half for each stage decided by a table, a pool title or a championship read from the standings. A pool with no winner, three tied and nothing to separate them, lifts nothing. Three or more a season honors; one, the conference title alone decided on the field, strains; a championship by table alone breaks.
Lore
The Golden Egg dates to 1927, the year after Ole Miss snapped a thirteen-game skid against Mississippi State and the students of both schools decided the game needed something to fight over besides the goalposts. The State Fair of Texas gave the Golden Hat in 1941 to thank Texas and Oklahoma for playing in Dallas every October. Arkansas and LSU had played for a century before anyone made the Golden Boot in 1996, and nobody has suggested giving it back. The trophy gave the rivalry a shape you could put your hands on.
Supported by
TTE Title EventDEF Decisive FinalPHS A Gumbo Game Has Stakes
Pulls against FOP Fresh Opponent PreferredTGA Thanksgiving Anchor
Seen in
| scenario | language | simulated | value |
|---|---|---|---|
| status-quo | × breaks | × breaks | 0.500 |
| pool-play | ~ strains | ~ strains | 2.309 |
| two-cups | ~ strains | ~ strains | 2.830 |
| two-cups-b | ~ strains | ~ strains | 2.612 |
| four-cups | + honors | + honors | 5 |
| pools-playoff | + honors | + honors | 4.624 |
| mini-playoff | + honors | + honors | 9 |
| chase | + honors | + honors | 4.121 |
| seven-settle | ~ strains | ~ strains | 1 |
| seven-final | ~ strains | ~ strains | 1 |
| seven-semis | ~ strains | ~ strains | 1 |
| eight-final | ~ strains | ~ strains | 1 |
- status-quo: breaks. One trophy, read from the standings.
- pool-play: strains. Four pool titles and a championship, all read from tables.
- two-cups: strains. Two cup finals and a super final when earned; under three most seasons.
- two-cups-b: strains. The same, with the super final skipped when the champions already met.
- four-cups: honors. Four cup finals and a final among champions.
- pools-playoff: honors. Eight pool titles by table and a final on the field.
- mini-playoff: honors. Eight pod finals and a final.
- chase: honors. Eight pool titles by table and a championship by table; many to lift, none after a final.
- seven-settle: strains. One conference final.
- seven-final: strains. One conference final.
- seven-semis: strains. One conference final.
See it: status-quopool-playtwo-cupstwo-cups-bfour-cupspools-playoffmini-playoffchaseseven-settleseven-finalseven-semiseight-final