PAYS
The Format Pays Its Way
Supports FOOT Footballness
Context
The SEC Championship Game began in 1992 in Birmingham with Alabama and Florida, moved to Atlanta, and became the most valuable single Saturday the conference owns. If it goes away, whatever replaces it has to earn its keep twice: it has to produce events worth televising and attending, and it has to send as many SEC teams as possible into the national playoff with their résumés intact. A format that is fair and sells nothing will not be adopted, and a format that sells plenty but sends the league's best teams into December with four extra losses will not be adopted twice.
Problem
Sorting makes the league's contenders take their losses from each other. A 4-0 team that spends November playing other 4-0 teams can finish 5-3 and look, to a committee in a hotel ballroom, like a team that collapsed, while a league with a soft fixed schedule sends three one-loss teams to the playoff. The better the conference sorts itself, the worse it looks from outside, unless the playoff guarantees the conference its seats.
Forces
- Events pull against rivalries. Every title event in November competes with a rivalry date for the Saturday and for attention.
- Events pull against freshness. The most valuable final is between the two best teams, who have likely met.
- Sorting pulls against bids. Every game between contenders is a loss for one of them that a softer schedule would not have charged.
- Bids pull against the season. Protecting résumés by avoiding contender games is exactly how the season stops being a playoff.
- The playoff's rules change the trade. If the conference is guaranteed a number of playoff seats, sorting costs nothing nationally, and if the seats are at large, every contender game is a bet.
Solution
Count the distinct title events a format produces on dates you can put on a calendar in March. Count, under each playoff rule, how many conference teams finish with a playoff-grade record. Report both, side by side, and let the conference choose where on that line it wants to live. Prefer formats whose events are real every year, and whose sorting is concentrated in enough games to be decisive but not so many that the contenders wear each other down.
Therefore
Produce title events you can sell in March, and do not send the league's best into December with losses the playoff committee will not forgive.
Patterns
- TTE, Title Event. How many scheduled championship events a season produces.
- BID, Protect the Bids. How many conference teams finish with a playoff-grade record, under each playoff rule.
Measure
Taken together: the number of real, scheduled title events per season, and the number of conference teams that come out of November looking like playoff teams. A format honors this principle when it has at least as much of the first as the old title game had, valued and not counted, and no fewer of the second than the old schedule had.
Lore
In 2024 the SEC sent three teams to the playoff and left a 9-3 Alabama at home while an 11-2 SMU and an 11-1 Indiana got in. Every one of Alabama's three losses was to a conference opponent, and the committee counted three losses and stopped there. A conference designing its own season has to assume the committee will keep doing that until the playoff's rules change.
Supported by
TTE Title EventBID Protect the Bids
Seen in
| scenario | language | simulated | value |
|---|---|---|---|
| status-quo | × breaks | ||
| pool-play | × breaks | ||
| two-cups | ~ strains | ||
| two-cups-b | ~ strains | ||
| four-cups | + honors | ||
| pools-playoff | ~ strains | ||
| mini-playoff | ~ strains | ||
| chase | × breaks | ||
| seven-settle | + honors | ||
| seven-final | + honors | ||
| seven-semis | + honors | ||
| eight-final | + honors |
- status-quo: breaks. There is no title event at all.
- pool-play: breaks. There is no final, and the top pool's last round is the closest thing.
- two-cups: strains. Two cup finals every year and a super final when earned, but the top of each bracket plays four straight contenders.
- four-cups: honors. Four cup finals and a final among champions, with shorter brackets.
- pools-playoff: strains. It has a real playoff, and the eight who make it can each take up to three more losses.
- mini-playoff: strains. The same holds.
- chase: breaks. There is no title event, and the top of the standings plays three Swiss weeks against each other.