CSF · measured by super final share
Super Final When Earned
Supports FELD Settled on the FieldDEF Decisive FinalTTE Title Event
Context
Two cups produce two champions. Some years it's the same school and there is nothing to settle, but most years it's two schools, and the whole conference wants to see them play. The trouble is arithmetic: nine conference games, with the last one a rivalry nobody will move, leaves eight for the structure, and a final bracket of k rounds leaves eight minus k for the stages that feed it.
Problem
One easy way out is to play the super final only when it fits, which means it happens rarely and never becomes a fixture. The other is a tenth game, which the conference won't play. What's left is to make the final the finalists' ninth game, on the second-to-last Saturday, and to find a fair answer for the two opponents they were supposed to play on the last one.
Forces
- The final pulls against the stages. Every Saturday the final bracket needs is one the cups and pools don't get, and two full sixteen-team championships cost eight games and leave nothing for a final.
- The final pulls against the last Saturday. The finalists' last-Saturday opponents are left without a game, so they are re-paired with each other: the two displaced rivals play each other, or a displaced SEC rival takes over the other finalist's ACC game. Every such game is a rivalry that wasn't played and an opponent nobody knew about in August, and the measures count it. When the two champions are already each other's Thanksgiving opponent, every other game stays as printed, and that is the best Saturday the conference can have.
- The final pulls against freshness. The two cup champions may have already met in a cup, and the final is played anyway.
- A rare game pulls against a sold game. A final that happens most years can be put in a contract, and one that happens one year in twenty can't.
Solution
See that every school has eight games done before the second-to-last Saturday. Play the final as the finalists' ninth game: on Thanksgiving Saturday when both their Thanksgiving opponents are being re-paired anyway, and a week early when one finalist's Thanksgiving game is the ACC one. Re-pair the two opponents the finalists were going to play on the last Saturday, SEC rival with SEC rival, or SEC rival into the ACC game the other finalist left behind, by a rule published before the season. When the finalists are a Thanksgiving pair, slide the final to the last Saturday instead, and every other game stays as printed. Count every re-paired game against the format where the rivalry, known-opponent, and venue measures live, and let the scorecard say what the final cost.
Therefore
Play the super final as the ninth game, re-pair whoever it displaces so nobody sits out, let the scorecard carry the cost, and never play a tenth game.
Measure
The share of seasons in which two or more different cup champions meet in a final, and beside it the number of last-Saturday games re-paired to make room for it.
Lore
Texas and Texas A&M played for a spot in Atlanta on Thanksgiving weekend 2024, and nobody in the state of Texas complained that the rivalry had been given extra weight. That is the one case where the final and the last Saturday belong together, and every other case has to be built into October.
Supported by
DEF Decisive FinalSCH Second ChanceWPL Winners' Path, Losers' PathNIN Nine and Done
Pulls against RRP Reserved Rivalry PairTGA Thanksgiving AnchorFOP Fresh Opponent PreferredSMP Sufficient Sample
Seen in
| scenario | language | simulated | value |
|---|---|---|---|
| status-quo | · n/a | · n/a | 0 |
| pool-play | · n/a | · n/a | 0 |
| two-cups | + honors | + honors | 0.912 |
| two-cups-b | ~ strains | ~ strains | 0.300 |
| four-cups | + honors | + honors | 1 |
| pools-playoff | · n/a | · n/a | 0 |
| mini-playoff | · n/a | · n/a | 0 |
| chase | · n/a | · n/a | 0 |
| seven-settle | · n/a | · n/a | 0 |
| seven-final | · n/a | · n/a | 0 |
| seven-semis | · n/a | · n/a | 0 |
| eight-final | · n/a | · n/a | 0 |
- two-cups: honors. Eight games are done by the second-to-last Saturday; the super final is the ninth for the two champions, and their last-Saturday opponents are re-paired.
- two-cups-b: strains. The super final is played only when the two champions have not met in a cup: one year in three (0.32), by design.
- four-cups: honors. Six cup games leave two Saturdays for a bracket of up to four distinct champions, with double winners first in line for the bye.
- Others: not applicable; one champion by standings or by a playoff of a chosen field.
See it: status-quopool-playtwo-cupstwo-cups-bfour-cupspools-playoffmini-playoffchaseseven-settleseven-finalseven-semiseight-final