RRP · measured by protected played
Reserved Rivalry Pair
Supports RIVL Rivalries Are KeptKOP Known OpponentsNSC Neutral-Site ClassicTGA Thanksgiving Anchor
Context
Each SEC school has three annual opponents it will not give up, twenty-four pairs in all. The Iron Bowl, the Egg Bowl, Texas and Texas A&M, Tennessee and Vanderbilt, Arkansas and Missouri are Thanksgiving-weekend games. Texas and Oklahoma play in Dallas in October, Florida and Georgia on neutral ground at the end of October, and Alabama and Tennessee on the Third Saturday in October, with the cigars coming out after; Auburn and Georgia is the Deep South's Oldest Rivalry. They are the schedule's reason for existing.
Problem
Any structure that picks opponents by results will, left alone, schedule a rivalry in September and burn it, or skip it because the two paths never crossed, or ask a finalist to play its final on the day it has always played its rival. A pairing rule has no idea what a rivalry is until somebody writes it in.
Forces
- Reservation pulls against adaptivity. Every reserved pair removes a pair from the solver's choices and a slot from the adaptive budget.
- Reservation pulls against collision. Two reserved rivals must be kept apart in every bracket and pool, or the structure plays them twice.
- Reservation pulls against the title path. A finalist's ninth game is the final, so its reserved rival is left standing on the last Saturday. The rival is re-paired, with the other finalist's displaced opponent, so nobody is abandoned, and the reserved game is counted as not played. This is the one thing allowed to override a reservation, it is written down before the season, and it costs the format on this measure.
Solution
Reserve the Thanksgiving pairs and the two neutral-site classics to fixed Saturdays outside every adaptive structure. Put each reserved pair in different groups in every partition. Put the remaining protected pairs into fixed opening rounds. Let the solver treat any still-unplayed protected pair as a priority in adaptive slots.
Therefore
Decide where each of the twenty-four is played before the season, as a fixed game or a reserved date, and let nothing override it but a final, which pays for the privilege here.
Measure
Protected pairs played per season out of twenty-four, and the share of seasons in which all twenty-four are played.
Lore
Texas and Texas A&M did not play from 2011 to 2023 because a conference line ran between them, and Thanksgiving weekend in Texas had a hole in it. Oklahoma and Nebraska, which used to own the day after Thanksgiving, play each other now about once a decade. A rivalry that is not reserved is a rivalry that will eventually be lost to something that seemed more important at the time.
Supported by
ORP Orthogonal PartitionsTGA Thanksgiving AnchorRIO Rivalry in the Opener
Pulls against LPL Like Plays LikeDEF Decisive FinalCSF Super Final When Earned
Seen in
| scenario | language | simulated | value |
|---|---|---|---|
| status-quo | + honors | + honors | 24 |
| pool-play | + honors | + honors | 24 |
| two-cups | ~ strains | ~ strains | 22.604 |
| two-cups-b | ~ strains | ~ strains | 23.237 |
| four-cups | ~ strains | ~ strains | 23.344 |
| pools-playoff | ~ strains | ~ strains | 23.335 |
| mini-playoff | ~ strains | ~ strains | 22.589 |
| chase | + honors | + honors | 24 |
| seven-settle | ~ strains | ~ strains | 23.284 |
| seven-final | + honors | + honors | 24 |
| seven-semis | ~ strains | ~ strains | 23.117 |
| eight-final | ~ strains | ~ strains | 22.871 |
- status-quo: honors. All twenty-four are fixed by construction.
- pool-play: honors. Pods, two rivalry weekends, the ACC four's extra Saturday, and Thanksgiving cover all twenty-four every season.
- two-cups: strains. Openers and the ninth game cover twenty-one before the season; Gumbo games pick up most of the other three, and the super final re-pairs two most years.
- four-cups: strains. Openers plus reserved pairs; a few depend on the solver finding them.
- pools-playoff: strains. Pools and Thanksgiving cover all twenty-four before the season, and the Gumbo games take an unplayed rival first, but the pairs the final breaks up are not always made whole: the league averages 23.3 of its twenty-four.
- mini-playoff: strains. Four fixed rounds cover twenty-two; the final re-pairs two most years.
- chase: honors. Pools plus reserved Saturdays cover all twenty-four.
- eight-final: strains. A finalist gives up its Thanksgiving rival to the final, so a pair or two go unplayed most seasons.
See it: status-quopool-playtwo-cupstwo-cups-bfour-cupspools-playoffmini-playoffchaseseven-settleseven-finalseven-semiseight-final