RIVL
Rivalries Are Kept
Supports FOOT Footballness
Context
Alabama and Auburn have played on the last Saturday of November for as long as most people alive can remember. Mississippi plays Mississippi State on Thanksgiving night. Texas and Oklahoma meet at the Cotton Bowl in October with the State Fair going on outside the gates, and Florida and Georgia meet on neutral ground at the end of the month. Four SEC schools finish the year against an ACC neighbor under a contract the SEC does not control. These games are the reason a lot of people care about the list at all.
Problem
Any format that chooses opponents by results will, left to itself, schedule a rivalry in September by accident, or skip it because the two schools' paths never crossed, or ask a finalist to play its final on the Saturday it has always played its rival. Nothing in a sorting rule knows what a rivalry is, so somebody has to write the rivalries in by hand.
Forces
- Rivalry pulls against sorting. Rivals rarely have the same record, so a rivalry game is one that sorting on its own would almost never pick.
- Rivalry pulls against the final. A final on the last Saturday takes that Saturday away from a rivalry, for the two finalists and for their two rivals.
- Rivalry pulls against the calendar. Fixed dates in October and November use up the slack every other part of the format wanted.
- Rivalry pulls against mercy. A rivalry in a knockout opener means your rival can end your title hopes in week one, and that is part of the point.
Solution
Decide before the season where each of the twenty-four protected games is played, as a fixed opener, a reserved Saturday, or a priority in an adaptive slot, and let nothing override it but a final, which is scored for what it displaces. Hold the last Saturday for Thanksgiving rivalries. Keep the two neutral-site classics on their date and their ground and make the rest of the format bend around them. Spend the fixed opening rounds on rivals.
Therefore
Name every rivalry's place in the season before the season starts, and keep it.
Patterns
- RRP, Reserved Rivalry Pair. How many of the twenty-four get played each year.
- TGA, Thanksgiving Anchor. Whether the last Saturday stays a rivalry Saturday.
- RIO, Rivalry in the Opener. How many rivalries are guaranteed by a fixed slot.
- NSC, Neutral-Site Classic. Whether Dallas and Jacksonville keep their dates.
Measure
Taken together: how many of the twenty-four protected games are played each season, and how many of them are played where and when they have always been played. A format honors this principle when the first is twenty-four and the second is nearly so.
Lore
Texas and Texas A&M did not play from 2011 through 2023 because a conference line ran between them, and everybody in the state knew exactly what had been lost. When the game came back on Thanksgiving weekend in 2024, the winner went to Atlanta, which is what a rivalry looks like when the format backs it up.
Supported by
RRP Reserved Rivalry PairTGA Thanksgiving AnchorRIO Rivalry in the OpenerNSC Neutral-Site Classic
Seen in
| scenario | language | simulated | value |
|---|---|---|---|
| status-quo | + honors | ||
| pool-play | ~ strains | ||
| two-cups | ~ strains | ||
| two-cups-b | ~ strains | ||
| four-cups | ~ strains | ||
| pools-playoff | ~ strains | ||
| mini-playoff | ~ strains | ||
| chase | + honors | ||
| seven-settle | ~ strains | ||
| seven-final | + honors | ||
| seven-semis | ~ strains | ||
| eight-final | ~ strains |
- status-quo: honors. All twenty-four are played, because the schedule names them.
- pool-play: strains. The September pools cover most of them, and the fixed games cover the rest.
- two-cups: strains. Openers and the ninth game cover twenty-one, and the other three depend on the bracket.
- four-cups: strains. Openers and reserved pairs cover most of them, and some depend on the solver.
- pools-playoff: strains. All twenty-four are reserved before the season, and the final re-pairs two of them most years.
- mini-playoff: strains. Four fixed rounds cover twenty-two, and the final re-pairs two of them most years.
- chase: honors. Pools plus reserved Saturdays cover all twenty-four every year.
- eight-final: strains. Every rivalry is on its date in August, and the final takes two of them most Novembers.