ORP · measured by structural overlap

Orthogonal Partitions

Context

Every format here plays two early stages over the same sixteen schools, and each stage cuts the field into groups. If a pair of schools lands in the same group both times, they are scheduled to meet twice before a single result is known. That is a rematch built into the schedule before anyone has played.

Problem

Overlap manufactures rematches before the season starts, and it spends two guaranteed-opponent slots on the same school.

Forces

  • Orthogonality pulls against group size. Four groups of four can be made fully orthogonal, with every pair of groups sharing exactly one school, but two groups of eight cannot, and the best you can do there is a three-and-five split.
  • Orthogonality pulls against rivalry coverage. Spreading protected pairs across both stages' openers competes with keeping the partitions clean.

Solution

Choose the second partition so that every group in it meets every group in the first in as few schools as possible, ideally exactly one. For four-team groups this is a Latin square. For eight-team groups, minimize the overlap and let cross-bracket consolation handle what remains.

Therefore

Never let two schools share a group in both stages when the group size allows it.

Measure

The number of school pairs that share a group in both stage partitions. Zero is achievable with four-team groups.

Lore

A Latin square is the puzzle on the back of the cereal box: four rows and four columns, with every symbol appearing once per row and once per column. Put the sixteen schools in the grid, make the rows one stage's pods and the columns the other's, and no two schools ever share a pod twice. Euler worked this out for a parade of officers in 1782, and it has been waiting for football ever since.

Supported by

Seen in

scenariolanguagesimulatedvalue
status-quo· n/a· n/a0
pool-play+ honors· n/a0
two-cups~ strains· n/a0
two-cups-b~ strains· n/a0
four-cups~ strains· n/a0
pools-playoff+ honors+ honors0
mini-playoff+ honors+ honors0
chase+ honors+ honors0
seven-settle· n/a· n/a0
seven-final· n/a· n/a0
seven-semis· n/a· n/a0
eight-final· n/a· n/a0
  • pool-play: honors. Rank bands draw one school from each first-stage pool.
  • two-cups: strains. Two full sixteen-team brackets must overlap; the seed orders are arranged so the first-round pairs differ.
  • four-cups: strains. Eight-team groups force overlap.
  • pools-playoff: honors. Two partitions with no pair shared.
  • mini-playoff: honors. Every cross-pod intersection is exactly one school.
  • chase: honors. The same partitions as Pools Playoff.

See it: status-quopool-playtwo-cupstwo-cups-bfour-cupspools-playoffmini-playoffchaseseven-settleseven-finalseven-semiseight-final