SORT
Like Plays Like
Supports SEAS The Season Is the Playoff
Context
Nine games is a small sample from a field of sixteen teams. You cannot play everybody, so the question is which nine you play, and the rotation's answer is whoever the wheel landed on two years ago. Chess solved this a century ago with the Swiss system, which pairs the players with the same score after each round. The information you need to rank a field is in the games between neighbors.
Problem
A nine-game schedule drawn without regard to results spends most of its games on mismatches that tell you nothing you did not know in August. The contenders beat the strugglers, the strugglers lose to the contenders, and in November you still cannot say which of three one-loss teams is best because they never met.
Forces
- Sorting pulls against rematches. Match the good against the good often enough and they run out of each other, so the pairing that tells you the most is also the one most likely to be a repeat.
- Sorting pulls against rivalry. Your rival's record has nothing to do with whether you play them, so the format has to leave room for games that sorting would never choose.
- Sorting pulls against knowing. Every opponent chosen by results is an opponent nobody knew in August.
- Coarse pulls against fine. Pools of four sort coarsely and are easy to explain, while week-by-week pairing sorts finely and needs a published rule a fan can apply by hand.
Solution
After an opening stage, match schools whose results so far are as alike as possible. Where the stage is a knockout, do it by bracket, with winners toward winners and losers toward losers, and where it is not, do it by rank band or by Swiss pairing. Partition the stages so no two schools can meet twice by construction, pool the eliminated across brackets so the pairing has room to breathe, and treat every repeat as a cost.
Therefore
Let standing choose the opponent, and build the stages so that standing rarely chooses the same opponent twice.
Patterns
- LPL, Like Plays Like. How close in record the opponents are in November.
- WPL, Winners' Path, Losers' Path. Whether every round pairs equal records.
- FOP, Fresh Opponent Preferred. How many of the seventy-two games are repeats.
- CBC, Cross-Bracket Consolation. Whether the eliminated get fresh opponents too.
- ORP, Orthogonal Partitions. Whether the stages are built so no pair shares a group twice.
Measure
Taken together: the win-loss gap between November opponents, and the number of repeated pairings it cost to close that gap. A format honors this principle when the gap is small and the repeats are few.
Lore
The Scottish Premiership has split its table after thirty-three rounds since the turn of the century so the top six play each other and the bottom six do the same. It is not pretty and the home-and-away counts come out uneven some years, but nobody up there argues that the last five rounds are dead. The sixteen-team WAC of the late nineties tried to do something like this with rotating quadrants and nobody could follow it. The lesson is that fans have to be able to follow the sorting or it is not worth the cost.
Supported by
LPL Like Plays LikeWPL Winners' Path, Losers' PathFOP Fresh Opponent PreferredCBC Cross-Bracket ConsolationORP Orthogonal Partitions
Seen in
| scenario | language | simulated | value |
|---|---|---|---|
| status-quo | × breaks | ||
| pool-play | + honors | ||
| two-cups | + honors | ||
| two-cups-b | + honors | ||
| four-cups | + honors | ||
| pools-playoff | ~ strains | ||
| mini-playoff | ~ strains | ||
| chase | + honors | ||
| seven-settle | ~ strains | ||
| seven-final | ~ strains | ||
| seven-semis | ~ strains | ||
| eight-final | ~ strains |
- status-quo: breaks. Opponents are set years ahead.
- pool-play: honors. Rank bands put the pool winners together and the pool losers together.
- two-cups: honors. Classification brackets pair equal records every round.
- four-cups: honors. The same holds, with a consolation pool across cups.
- pools-playoff: strains. The round robins do not sort, and only the playoff does.
- mini-playoff: strains. The pod's second round sorts within four, and the rivalry rounds do not sort at all.
- chase: honors. Swiss pairing on the standings picks the November opponents.