CBC · measured by consolation repeats

Cross-Bracket Consolation

Context

Run two brackets side by side over the same sixteen schools and each bracket's losers' side is small and crowded. An eight-team bracket's four first-round losers have only each other to play, and two of them probably met in the other bracket a month ago. The trophy is decided on the winners' path, and the rematches pile up on the losers' side, where fewer people are watching.

Problem

Strict classification inside one bracket forces rematches among the eliminated, because the geometry leaves the solver no choice. The games that were supposed to give the beaten something to play for hand them the same opponent they already lost to.

Forces

  • Choice pulls against identity. Merging consolation pools across brackets widens the pairing choice but loosens the bracket's shape in the fan's mind.
  • Choice pulls against venue. The merged pool must still honor each school's published home or away slot for that round, so it is split into a home-designated half and an away-designated half and matched across.

Solution

Keep the unbeaten championship paths rigid inside each bracket. Pool the eliminated from both brackets into one consolation pool per round, split by published venue, and assign opponents by minimum-cost matching with repeats and reserved rivals forbidden and prior results used to steer away from any rematch.

Therefore

Let losers cross brackets, and never let winners cross.

Measure

Repeated pairings per season within consolation rounds only.

Lore

The old sixteen-team WAC put its schools in four rotating quadrants and nobody could tell you who was in which, and it died of that confusion in three years. The rule here is that the part fans look at, the winners' path, stays simple and rigid, and the complexity goes to the consolation rounds, where the cameras aren't.

Supported by

Pulls against WPL Winners' Path, Losers' Path

Seen in

scenariolanguagesimulatedvalue
status-quo· n/a· n/a0
pool-play· n/a· n/a0
two-cups+ honors+ honors0.048
two-cups-b+ honors+ honors0.048
four-cups~ strains~ strains0.841
pools-playoff~ strains· n/a0.638
mini-playoff~ strains· n/a0.671
chase· n/a· n/a0
seven-settle· n/a· n/a0.017
seven-final· n/a· n/a0
seven-semis· n/a· n/a0.021
eight-final· n/a· n/a0
  • two-cups: honors. Consolation games are paired across the whole eliminated pool each round.
  • four-cups: strains. Cross-cup pairing with fixed venues cuts the early repeats, but each cup's beaten are a small pool, and a rematch among them comes most years.
  • pools-playoff: strains. Gumbo games exist but aren't organized as a matched pool.
  • mini-playoff: strains. Pod loser games stay inside the pod.
  • Others: not applicable; no parallel brackets.

See it: status-quopool-playtwo-cupstwo-cups-bfour-cupspools-playoffmini-playoffchaseseven-settleseven-finalseven-semiseight-final