NIN · measured by calendar fit

Nine and Done

Context

The season has fourteen Saturdays, from the end of August to the Saturday after Thanksgiving. Each school plays nine conference games and three out of conference and takes two byes, which makes seventy-two conference games in all, with nothing in December. Four schools have ACC games on the last Saturday, and two neutral classics sit on fixed October dates. Every format has to fit inside that.

Problem

Every structure wants more Saturdays than exist. A final, a rivalry round, two classics, and three-round stages do not all fit without somebody getting a special case, and a special case is a rule nobody remembers and a fan who feels cheated.

Forces

  • Rounds pull against Saturdays. Two stages of three rounds, a two-round final, and a rivalry round is nine conference Saturdays, leaving five for everything else and no slack for the classics.
  • Symmetry pulls against the four. The four ACC-rivalry schools need a different November, so any solution gives them a different shape from the other twelve.
  • Slack pulls against guarantees. A format with no slack cannot absorb a hurricane, and this is the Gulf Coast.

Solution

Build the calendar as a template that lists every school on every Saturday, and prove the game counts hold under every result path. Prefer designs whose template needs no exception that depends on results, and where one cannot be avoided, give it a name and a rule.

Therefore

A format that needs a result-dependent calendar fix it cannot name is not finished.

Measure

The share of simulated seasons in which every school plays exactly nine conference games. Anything less than every season is a broken calendar.

Lore

Hurricane Katrina moved LSU's home opener to Arizona State in 2005. Florida and LSU lost their October date to Matthew in 2016 and had to play in Baton Rouge in November on a Saturday both had held open for other things, and the argument over who gave up what went on for weeks. A calendar with slack can absorb a storm, and one without it ends in a press conference.

Supported by

Pulls against DEF Decisive FinalNSC Neutral-Site Classic

Seen in

scenariolanguagesimulatedvalue
status-quo+ honors+ honors1
pool-play+ honors+ honors1
two-cups+ honors+ honors1
two-cups-b+ honors+ honors1
four-cups+ honors+ honors1
pools-playoff+ honors+ honors1
mini-playoff+ honors+ honors1
chase+ honors+ honors1
seven-settle+ honors+ honors1
seven-final+ honors+ honors1
seven-semis+ honors+ honors1
eight-final+ honors+ honors1
  • status-quo: honors.
  • pool-play: honors. Three stages of three games on fixed dates.
  • two-cups: honors. Two four-round cups and a ninth game fit the fourteen.
  • four-cups: honors. Every school has nine, three, and two in every simulated season once the Classic stands alone.
  • pools-playoff: honors. The same, nine, three, and two for everyone every season.
  • mini-playoff: honors. Nine, three, and two for everyone in every season; the final week settles the ACC four and the displaced.
  • chase: honors. The template fits; the four ACC schools play all three adaptive weeks.

See it: status-quopool-playtwo-cupstwo-cups-bfour-cupspools-playoffmini-playoffchaseseven-settleseven-finalseven-semiseight-final